Blog Posts

Hannes at LIFT09: Day 1. "Where did the future go?"

LIFT09

Hi. I'm currently at LIFT09 in Geneva, and after the workshop I moderated yesterday, I could start enjoying - if only the whole thing wouldn't be slightly disappointing overall.

Well, the workshop was about asking the conference's motto questions "Where did the future go?" with regard to that meta-utopia we call the Semantic Web. Slightly too technical at times, the discussion went pretty well indeed, the Café Method proved to be helpful once again. The participants, among them folks from Mozilla, DFKI, Swisscom, UBS etc. etc (and of course the Dreamlab guys), were pretty hard to stop discussing - a good sign. In the discussion, the actual usefulness of many of the standards and ideas around in the Semantic Web space were heavily challenged, I'll have to reflect a bit for giving you a good summary.

The disappointment comes mainly from the impression of declining density, compared to the three LIFT conferences I attended before. More repetitions of topics previously covered, again a seemingly lower number of presentations, and an overall level that does not seem to rise. Maybe the future just went away, on holiday. Or maybe it's just me.

Instead of liveblogging or such, I'll just be mentioning a couple of pointers here over the next couple of days, all the content of LIFT is going to be online very soon indeed. A very nice presentation this morning was the one by David Rose of Ambient Devices showing us .. ambient devices (or rather "enchanted objects"), actually working ones, like the 1-Pixel-Browser and so on.

After that Lee Bryant had 5 minutes, and he was good. Explained how the 20th century was basically and generally wrong, told us that trust is cheaper than control, told us to stick with a traditional mode of organizations: social networks. Network-based models are proven an aggregation and links beats coercion. Yes indeed.

Related Entries:
- Lift08 - Day 03 - Final Session on Foresight
- Lift08 - Day 03 - The Web and entreprises Track
- Lift08 - Day 3 - The Gaming Track
- Lift08 - Day 3 - The New Frontiers Track
- LIFT08 - Day 2 - A morning full of keynotes

Comments [2]

Adrian Kosmaczewski, 26.02.2009 14:07 CEST

I've been to LIFT in 07, and it was already a pretty disappointing experience. To put it bluntly, I found that the debates were as shallow as they could be, and it seemed like the whole event is actually a big excuse for networking and making feel people like they were "in". Most people didn't give a damn sh** about the subjects (which in some rare cases were interesting but as I said shallow) and were merely there to collect cards and try to get informations about what's going on.

Let's put this clear, people; this is not Silicon Valley, and LIFT is not TED. Bigger things are happening elsewhere as for having the need to listen to UBS guys talking about the Semantic Web. Geez.

Karim farnami, 22.07.2010 00:38 CEST

Dear gassert
I am an Iranian Engineer who visited you in Lale Park of Tehran in your touristic travel to some ountries
I remember you always. Be in touch with us
your Iranian friend K.Farnami

Add a comment

Your email adress will never be published. Comment spam will be deleted!